A Citizen’s View: A Divided Trempealeau County Board
I attended the Trempealeau County Board meeting on October 12, 2026. It was a special meeting outside the regular monthly schedule, costing taxpayers an additional $2,000 beyond the annual budget. Approximately 25 citizens attended, but public participation was not permitted.
Chairman Andy Todd opened the meeting after the Pledge of Allegiance and provided an overview of the reasons for the meeting. A petition signed by nine supervisors allowed a motion to remove him as chairman by a majority vote. He made his case, and I could tell the experience was emotionally uncomfortable for him.
Several supervisors spoke, presenting arguments both against Chairman Todd and in his defense. It is worth noting that Todd had been elected only six months earlier. One supervisor said they had been unaware of the additional cost to taxpayers. When the supervisors finished speaking, Chairman Todd asked for clarification on specific points. In my opinion, clear answers were not provided, and misunderstandings had clearly occurred.
After everyone had been heard, Chairman Todd tried to bring the matter to a vote. However, one supervisor wanted to express a grievance and raised the issue of filing a complaint about supervisors’ relatives serving on committees. The matter was discussed extensively, with input and a full explanation from legal counsel. Concerns about transparency in committee decisions, or the lack thereof, were also raised.
The board then voted on whether to use paper ballots or an open roll-call vote. Only five members voted in favor of paper ballots. This seemed counterintuitive to me because those five supervisors had expressed a desire for greater transparency. The audience appeared to favor an open roll-call vote.
The roll-call vote on the motion to remove Chairman Todd ended in an 8-8 tie, causing the motion to fail. The noise level in the room increased, and, in my opinion, the audience’s reaction favored Todd. I looked up from my notepad and could tell from their facial expressions which eight supervisors had voted for his removal. Their expressions made me reflect on just how divisive this experience had been. It seemed to me that this group had gone all in on an opportunity to gain power and control of the board, and the effort had failed.
Local politics affects more aspects of my daily life than the federal government does. I expect elected county board leaders to act like adults, debate with decorum, and always work toward outcomes that serve the best interests of Trempealeau County. If one individual disrupts that process, any action taken should serve the interests of all parties concerned, not just one group.
I hope the board will work together to address the issues discussed at this meeting for the benefit of Trempealeau County residents. Our choices in the upcoming midterm elections will have consequences, so choose wisely.
Thank you for taking the time to read this. I hope it provides some clarity from a citizen’s point of view.
There is 1 Comment
Thanks for attending and sharing a first hand observation.
The really sad part is that Andy Todd is a person of very high character and the most honorable person to serve in that role for a long time. Simple-minded people with a desire to have control are destructive.
Add new comment